During my 5 day blogging hiatus, I was stuck with my father in Beijing, China. To tell the truth, I was rather underwhelmed by the whole experience, except for the prices of course (because 1 Singapore Dollar = 5 Chinese Yuan). The food was rather awful compared to Singapore’s (EXCEPT for the ROAST DUCK, OH LORD THE DUCK!!!), and the air quality in general was REALLY crappy compared to Singapore’s. Bargaining for stuff in the markets was really fun though. My father managed to bag 30 socks for a mere SGD16 (about 80 Chinese yuan) and a lot of other stuff at insanely low prices that I don’t really want to mention.
So half-way through the trip I told myself, why not get some Chinese translated manga and/or light novels as fun souveniers? I was aware Chinese adapted manga was published in “mini-omnibus” form (3 volumes bundled together), which sacrificed cover art. I couldn’t really accept this, as cover art was one aspect of manga that I enjoyed and appreciated. Thus, I wasn’t too keen on the manga. But I did remember seeing the Kanon light novels licensed in simplified Chinese somewhere in Singapore, and hoped that I could find some.
I decided that this bookstore looked rather promising, so I hopped in to have a look. To my dismay, the “manga world” section of the bookstore had really shitty stuff. Some guidebooks on how to draw manga, some really ugly looking artbooks and some Shoujo-ish looking manga with Bishounens and what not. Almost totally turned me off.
I didn’t want to give up on the light novels though, although something was telling me that I should. Light novels were literally translated into Qing (1) Xiao (3) Shuo (1) or 轻小说 in Chinese and there is actually a section devoted to them in the local Kinokuniya Orchard branch.
The bookstore staff told me they didn’t know what the heck was 轻小说. Actually upon further enquiry, I realised they didn’t really know much about the damned bookstore. So I had no choice but to comb the bookstore myself.
And GUESS WHAT I FOUND:
A cache of ADV Manga!
These manga must have been sitting on these shelves for 5 years or so. For those uninitiated with manga news, the ARIA manga on the shelf is already out of print. Presently, Tokyopop has taken over the ARIA manga license from ADV Manga. This was a really huge find for me as I am a rather staunch ARIA fan, and I scooped up a copy immediately to add to my ARIA collection. Probably can’t find this anywhere else in the world OR the internet.
I also found it rather amusing that the managers of the bookstore classified ARIA as a children’s book. Quite honestly, if my mother gave me ARIA to read when I was 8, I would be bored stiff. ARIA is a slow-paced slice-of-life science-fiction Seinen manga, and I doubt anyone below the age of 18 would find it interesting.
And I actually burst out laughing when I saw what was shelved next to the ARIA manga:
The manga adaption of To Heart, a popular eroge. I swear I WILL SUE the pants off the bookstore if I find my daughter flipping through an eroge adaption.
The manga on the right shelf look mostly safe, except for yet another freaking eroge adaption (can you figure out which one?). And the worst part is that this one is rated 17+ and not really censored that well.
Well, it isn’t really an eroge adaption. But it WAS serialised in Dengeki G’s, not exactly a magazine you would want children to read.
Honestly, even if you choose to be ignorant about manga, isn’t it at least a minimum requirement to flip through the stuff you are going to shelve in your bookstore instead of just buying a bunch of manga at a bargain price from a random publisher?
Well, that’s a Chinese bookstore for you: Shitty book classification and shitty customer service. I agree with my father when he mused multiple times during the trip that “Beijing isn’t ready for the Olympics”. Had a really nasty experience at the hotel as well T_T






8 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 18, 2008 at 12:05 am
Anonymous
I have some Kanon anthology comics, which I was “lol surprised” to find in the general section my local secondhand bookstore, full color “pinup” drawings and all. /e/ if you know what I mean. Actually saw the TH ones too but the artwork turned me off.
But hey, stuff like Kanon and TH work pretty well even without the ero, as evidenced by the all ages versions!
But yeah, outside of Japan I guess the mainstream perception is that if it’s 2D it must be for children hehe…
April 18, 2008 at 11:09 am
monsterpoke
I chanced upon the exact same “promising” bookshop in favour for the other smaller ones along the streets. I did purchase an English novel, at about a fraction of a cost of what it would have been sold locally.
And I don’t think the manga was housed there for ages, as I remembered combing the bookstore rather thoroughly, especially the “Imported Novel” section. I could only find some rather dubious Chinese edition of manga, the titles I have forgotten long ago. As well as tons of “legal” anime series in the video section…
That was about two years then, and you have to admit that it caters mainly to the “mainstream” tastes of the Chinese people, since I suppose its a rather “niche” segment of market for them to cater to. The approach does seem to be similar to what our neighbourhood Popular bookstore does: A mish-mash of a glut of items but non too specialised…except for assessment and textbooks?
I guess the Chinese bookshop isn’t aiming on acquiring as big a catalogue as Kinokuniya does. But I do agree that this hardly gives them excuse for their rather dismal cataloging of books…
And Yes, the Roast Duck is indeed FTW! And I can’t wait for the Haruhi Light Novelsto hit our shores!
April 18, 2008 at 9:28 pm
dood
i’m still been searching for so long for ARIA vol 2 (I have vol’s 1+3)
does anyone know where can it be ordred online ? (any used books store or the like [not ebay])
we only have like 3-4 stores which even sells comics and they don’t keep old ones (Vol 3 i found in a “bargain bin” -_-)
April 18, 2008 at 10:22 pm
dKiWi
@monsterpoke:
Thanks a whole bunch for the heads up about the Haruhi light novels!
However, the publisher name seems rather edgy since the novels are clearly Seinen and not intended for children (Young Readers? Like, how young man?). Noizi Itou, the novel’s illustrator, was originally an eroge character designer. Not to mention that Nagaru Tanigawa’s fiction contains a ton of references to advanced physics anomalies and Japanese culture.
Although I would rather have Seven Seas publish it in their original palm sized light novel format, but I guess that will never happen now. Hardcover version for a light novel seems really funny to me, and I’m not willing to buy it for the increased price as it lowers the authenticity of the publication.
I do buy original Japanese light novels for the sake of collection and authenticity from local Kinokuniya bookstores and amazon.co.jp
@dood:
I believe that finding the ADV Manga version of ARIA volume 1 in 2008 is already a rather incredible feat, so I wish you much luck in finding volume 2
April 19, 2008 at 3:06 pm
monsterpoke
Yup, I also share some of your concerns, especially that of content reproduction and translation problems. Hopefully, the supposed “joint publishing venture between Yen Press and Little, Brown Books for Young Readers” will prove to be fruitful and stay as true to the original content as much as possible.
If the above scenario bombs, well, I guess cross-referencing to the Chinese version as well as the ongoing “translation project wiki” will hopefullly be suffice in enlightening us on the original content as much as possible…
There will be two versions of the light novel to be published, I think. Both the paperback and the hardcover editions will be on sale on 1 April 2009, which is indeed a rather long wait…
April 29, 2008 at 8:47 am
beijinger
You picked the wrong bookstore. If you’d walked a little further up the street, the end of Wangfujing has another bookstore called the 外文书店, that actually has imported Japanese magazines (tons) and manga on the third floor, though all in Japanese. They do have some in English in the children’s section, in the English section.
April 30, 2008 at 9:30 pm
dKiWi
I actually went down to that one as well and wanted to buy some light novels, but they’re even more expensive than local kino so maybe not..
May 2, 2008 at 1:14 am
The hidden dangers in Japanese cartoons « 2D > 3D
[...] fact is Keroro Gunsou isn’t for kids. Happy Lesson isn’t for kids. ARIA isn’t for kids. I think we need a closet Otaku in any of the [...]